Friday, March 08, 2013

Pre-Trial Chamber I to Decide If Laurent Gbagbo, Former President of Cote d'Ivoire, to Face Trial

Pre-Trial Chamber I held a confirmation of charges hearing for Laurent Gbagbo, former president of Côte d'Ivoire. Photo: Michael Kooren/Reuters
By Maryne Rondot

Pre-Trial Chamber I of the ICC held a confirmation of charges hearing from February 19-28 to decide whether the case of Laurent Gbagbo, the former president of Côte d’Ivoire, should go to trial. Following this hearing, the three-judges panel will determine within 60 days of the final filings whether Gbagbo case to confirm the charges.

Gbagbo, who was president of Côte d’Ivoire from 2000 to 2011, is allegedly responsible as indirect co-perpetrator for four counts of crimes against humanity, allegedly committed in the context of post-electoral violence in the territory of Côte d’Ivoire between December 16, 2010 and April 12, 2011. The charges under examination by the Pre-Trial Chamber include murder; rape and other sexual violence; persecution; and other inhuman acts. Côte d’Ivoire was not a state party to the ICC at the time of the alleged crimes but accepted the jurisdiction of the Court on April 18, 2003 by a declaration made in accordance with the Rome Statute. It ratified the Rome Statute on February 15, 2013 and will become a State Party on May 1, 2013. Following a formal investigation in the Prosecutor’s own initiative, the Court issued a warrant of arrest for Laurent Gbagbo on October 25, 2011. He was transferred to the ICC detention center at The Hague by Ivorian authorities on November 23, 2011. He is the first head of state to face the ICC.

During this public hearing, the Prosecutor and the defense presented their arguments to the three judges of Pre-Trial Chamber I. Victims also had the opportunity to intervene and present their views through their legal representatives.

Defense Arguments

The defense called for charges to be dropped around three main points. First, it contested the admissibility of the case before the Court pointing out that Côte d’Ivoire has shown its willingness and capacity to investigate and prosecute Gbagbo itself. The defense argued that the principle of complementarity guaranteed by the Rome Statute "is not an option recognized to national courts but rather an obligation." The second part of the defense strategy was to question the quality of the Prosecutor's work. In this regard, they claimed that the investigation was not conducted properly since it only relies on a "construction of events that has been put together by others" - meaning NGOs. It also pointed out that the process of the Prosecutor was objectionable because she referred to actual events but she drew "hazardous interpretations" from them in order to prove a supposed intention of Gbagbo to stay in power. For example, the defense criticized the fact that the Prosecutor interpreted the slogan of Gbago’s election campaign "Gagner ou gagner" ("Win or win") as one element proving its intention to remain in power. The defense argued that it is simply a popular expression even used by the national football team. The defense finally questioned the partiality of the ICC since it is not prosecuting the “Ouattara side” - referring to current President Alassane Outtara - even though it had also been accused of committing serious crimes during the post-electoral violence.

In a brief statement at the end of the confirmation of charges hearing on February 28, Gbagbo defended himself especially concerning his presumed intention to stay in power undemocratically. He declared, “I am here because I respected the constitution.” He claimed that he has been a strong advocate for democracy for a very long time because he believes it is the only way for Africa to build its nations. In his view, democracy helps to overcome tensions between heterogeneous groups and gives each of them a voice. He also explained that he believed his case will not be addressed properly without considering what happened during the elections. He argued that “democracy is not only the vote but who tells the result of the vote." He finally argued that this is the ones who lost the election, Ouattara and his allies, who caused the turmoil.

Prosecution Arguments
In response, the prosecution complained about the defense's last-minute application challenging the admissibility of the case, considering it as a delaying tactic. In her opening statement, the Prosecutor declared that her office would demonstrate that Gbagbo "bears the greatest responsibility for some of the worst crimes committed in Côte d’Ivoire during the post-election crisis of 2010-2011." She considered that there is evidence that Gbabgo and his inner circle "adopted a policy and common plan" to stay in power by any means including force. According to the prosecution, Gbabgo was not only aware of what was happening but he "was the one calling the shots." This is supported by evidence gathered by the OTP, including Gbagbo's orders to use the army against demonstrators or the appointment of his supporters to key positions in government and in the security services.

The prosecution also emphasized the necessity of bringing justice for the victims of the crimes. The prosecution claims that Gbagbo is responsible for the "killing of at least 166 persons, the rape of at least 34 women and girls, the infliction of serious bodily injury and suffering on at least 94 persons and for committing the crime of persecution against at least 294 victims." Regarding the issue of partiality, the Prosecutor argued that a second warrant of arrest was issued for Simone Gbagbo (the wife of the ex-president) and that the investigations will continue. This means that other warrant arrest could be issued and other persons could be tried.

Views of Victims
Paolina Massidda, the Principal Counsel within the Office of Public Counsel for Victims called for the confirmation of all the charges against Gbagbo. She corroborated the arguments of the prosecution, especially concerning the intention of Gbagbo through "a common plan" to remain in power. She also stated that the alleged crimes presented by the prosecution were widespread and generalized and targeted not only the "rebels" but the civil population, independent of any political stance. Massidda underlined the suffering of the victims. She mentioned the traumatic impact of those crimes on the lives of the victims, the loss of their means to survive, their stigmatization within the Ivorian society and the fact that some of them were still living near the alleged perpetrators of crimes. She concluded that the victims have the right to impartial justice and truth about the events that occurred and reparations through individual and collective processes.

The parties have the opportunity to submit written arguments following the hearing. Judges should make the decision to either send the case to trial by the end of June.


Anonymous said...

[url=]{isabel marant|isabel marant|isabel marant|isabel marant shop online
[url=]{sac longchamp pas cher|sac longchamp pas cher|longchamp soldes|sac pliage longchamp}[/url] #file_links[C:\111\post\longchamp1.txt,1,n]
[url=]{longchamp|longchamp sac|longchamp|longchamp sac|sac longchamp pliage}[/url] #file_links[C:\111\post\longchamp1.txt,1,n]


Anonymous said...

Thanks for finally writing about > "Pre-Trial Chamber I to Decide If Laurent Gbagbo, Former President of Cote d'Ivoire, to Face Trial" < Loved it!

Also visit my web site - bmi for women chart

Anonymous said...

bookmarked!!, I really like your site!

My page; how to find a job overseas

Anonymous said...

I always emailed this webpage post page to all my associates, for the reason that if like to read it
then my contacts will too.

Also visit my web blog perfect waist to hip ratio

Anonymous said...

Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a
very well written article. I will be sure to
bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information.

Thanks for the post. I will definitely comeback.

Feel free to surf to my webpage ... online roulette

Anonymous said...

What's uup friends, fastidious pos and pleasant urging commented here, I
am really enjoying by these.

Heere iis myy blog :: league of angels hack facebook

Anonymous said...

This is to keep scars as less severe as possible with
fewer complications. incredibly popular for use in cosmetic breast augmentation surgery.
Fat transfer breast augmentation ensures natural looking results,
but it is important that you get the procedure done by a reliable plastic surgeon at an accredited plastic surgery

My weblog: breast augmentation boca raton

Anonymous said...

Excellent article. I absolutely love this website.

Have a look at my web site ::

Anonymous said...

If you are going fօr most eҳcellent contentss liкe I do, only pay a visit thіs sіtfe every dаy since it proviɗes գuality contents, thanks

Also visit my web page ... remove stretch marks after pregnancy

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to tell my little brother, that he should also pay a visit this blog
on regular basis to take updated from most up-to-date news.

Here is my site ... wiecej porad tutaj (

Anonymous said...

I absolutely love your blog and find a lot of your post's to
be just what I'm looking for. Does one offer guest writers to write
content to suit your needs? I wouldn't mind creating a post or elaborating on most of the subjects you write in relation to here.
Again, awesome site!

My page; flex shot as seen on tv ()

Anonymous said...

Hi there, I read your new stuff regularly. Your humoristic style is
witty, keep it up!

Also visit my blog post website

Anonymous said...

Great article, exactly what I needed.

Here is my web page :: makeup tips carmindy